January 4, 2016
I vow to post a blog entry every month this year. I have often broken my vows. But still, I make them.
I will list the movies I watched in the last month and the books I read.
My list of books read is quite short. It’s basically only one book. Felix Holt, The Radical the 1866 George Eliot novel. I’m going so slowly it’s surprises even me. And in general I’m a quite slow reader. I think I’ve been reading it for over four months. I read deliberately slowly, and read every footnote. I reread sentences, and I read each chapter over again. In addition, I’ve listened to the audio version twice while walking to the beach – and the audio I have is really superb. It’s performed by Nadia May, which is her “voice” name – her real name is Wanda McCaddon and she records under several different names. She’s fantastic with all the different British accents, which is very important.
I’m bewitched by George Eliot – and there’s so much more to read before I’m done. This is what I haven’t read: Daniel Doronda, Romola, The Impressions of Theophrastus Such, and countless poems, essays, and other biographies.
In the last year or two I’ve read Middlemarch, Adam Bede, Silas Marner, The Mill on the Floss, and Scenes of Clerical Life. I’m seized by Eliot’s voice, her world-view, her compassion, and most of all, her humor.
I’ve read the biography: George Eliot, the Last Victorian, written by Kathryn Hughes. I’ve listened to that audiobook (also by Nadia May) twice through. And to think it all started with the delightful (and for me, life-changing) book My Life in Middlemarch by Rebecca Mead. One early morning I heard Mead on NPR talking about her book and her own obsession with Middlemarch. I read Mead’s book and I was off and into one of the most pleasurable, enlightening, profound and perspective-altering wormholes of my life. I’m so happy here in George Eliot-land. There’s still so much to read and then there’s all the rereading I plan to do. If I do nothing else, goddamnit, I will be a George Eliot complete-ist.
So yes, my list of books read in December 2015 is really one: Felix Holt, the Radical. It’s been so delightful and worrisome reading this book (partly about politics, rural England in the 1820s) while people like Donald Trump (who I loathe) and Bernie Sanders (who I admire deeply) are out campaigning. Bernie could be a Felix. Trump is… well, there’s no easy character to point to for him. Trump is more bombastic as a candidate than anyone in Felix Holt. Harold Transome (a character, and a political candidate in Felix Holt) has more humanity and dignity than Trump, but their views about woman are probably quite similar. The character that Trump most reminds me of, from what I’ve been viewing recently – frankly is… Hitler. That reads quite bombastic. I don’t think Trump would put a machine in place to systematically kill certain ethnic groups. I don’t think. But I did think of Trump when I watched Triumph.
You see, I watched Leni Reifenstahl’s Triumph of the Will for the first time last week. There’s a new 2015 re-master out on Blu Ray. My friend Ron Falzone informed me that the commentary on the release, by Dr. Anthony R. Santoro (of Christopher Newport University, a Nazi and fascism historian) was really good. The whole film was chilling, and fascinating. Each time one of the Hitler power-circle comes onto the screen, Santoro simply informs the viewers what happened to them in the end: how they died, or how many years they spent in jail, etc. What was surprising to watch for me was Hitler’s idiosyncrasies; the minutea that reveal him as a human being. An addled, narcissistic human being. But still. Hitler has become a cartoon in our popular culture, but what makes him even more menacing and frightening is that that he is not a cartoon! He is a man with certain tendencies and inclinations who was able to get an enormous amount of power. And one way he did this was by speachifying. So what entranced me was how how Hitler holds his head, or how he would break out in a little self-satisfied smile when something he said came off well with the crowd – things I have not seen in any fictionalized portrayal, as good as some of those have been. (For me, the best being Bruno Ganz in Downfall.)
In any case, there were similarities. Both Hitler and Trump use an ideolized fictional past, when the countries were “great” and gather steam from people imaginging a return to a nostalgic idea that has nothing to do with reality. They both behave as if problems can be solved easily, that immigrants are to blame, and he exploits the frustrations of an under-educated class that is grasping at whatever privilege they think they can maintain, especially if it’s over another group of people. It’s a way to make disenfranchised people to feel better about themselves.
Of course Hitler is truly an unfair analogy - really it’s any popular dictator.
So, I suppose that the topic of Triumph of the Will brings me to movies.
But first!
I just remembered that I’ve read a couple of other books last month – Gratitude by Oliver Sachs, a small quick book of his essays before he died – just lovely. I also read about half of Kathleen McCormack’s delightful George Eliot in Society: Travels Abroad and Sundays at the Priory, another historical biography, however this one is mostly centered on Marian Evans and George Lewes Sunday salons over the years. And I read about half of Mendocino Fire, a compilation of short stories by Elizabeth Tallent, who I find thrilling and absorbing.
Movies I watched in December 2015:
(not in any particular order)
- The Big Short, 2015, directed by Adam McKay
- Love and Mercy, 2015, directed by Bill Pohlad
- Carol, 2015, directed by Todd Haynes
- Straight Outta Compton, 2015, directed by F. Gary Gray
- An Autumn Afternoon, 1962, directed by Yasujiro Ozu
- Late Autumn, 1960, directed by Yasujiro Ozu
- Steve Jobs, 2015, directed by Danny Boyle
- Sicario, 2015, directed by Denis Villeneuve
- Trumbo, 2015, directed by Jay Roach
- Grandma, 2015, directed by Paul Weitz
- Trainwreck, 2015, directed by Judd Apatow
- Infinitely Polar Bear, 2015, directed by Maya Forbes
- Black Mass, 2015, directed by Scott Cooper
- Spotlight, 2015, directed by Tom McCarthy
- Inside Out, 2015, directed by Pete Docter & Ronnie Del Carmen
- Dead Man, 1995, directed by Jim Jarmusch
- Pather Panchali, 1955, directed by Satyajit Ray
- Bridge of Spies, 2015, directed by Steven Spielberg
- After the Tour, 2015, directed by James Ponsoldt
- Triumph of the Will, 1935, directed by Leni Riefenstahl
- Clouds of Sils Maria, 2015, directed by Olivier Assayas
- Joy, 2015, directed by David O. Russell
- The Hateful Eight, 2015, directed by Quentin Tarantino
- My Neighbor Totoro, 1988, directed by Hayao Miyazaki
- The Martian, 2015, directed by Ridley Scott.
Well, a lot of movies this month. I was so happy to finally get around to Satyajit Ray, who I’ve been meaning to delve into for a very long time. In November I watched his film, The Music Room, which I liked very, very much. I can’t wait to find time to see the other two films in the Apu trilogy.
At the end of the year I end up seeing may too many new films. But as I am eligible to vote with the WGA, I feel I must try to see so many. I voted today for the nominations, and still felt terrible because I had not seen so many films I meant to see before I voted.
So far, I would say that my top 3 films this year are: Carol, Spotlight, and Inside Out. I also thought Love and Mercy was terrific. And Bridge of Spies! Oooooh, that was gooooood. Maybe that’s at the top too. And Clouds of Sils Maria. And Straight Outta Compton. I can’t put them in order. Oh! I forgot The Big Short! I saw it twice, I liked it so much. (Same with Spotlight. And I’m gonna watch it AGAIN this weekend. I also saw Inside Out twice.) And The Martian! So wonderful. “I’m gonna science the shit outta this-” should be a slogan for everyone all the time. Wow. Maybe The Martian is my number #1.
If I deeply enjoy a movie, I gotta see it again. It’s like, the first time around you’re on a roller coaster and the thrill of it, the discovery of it, is like the unexpected twists and turns on a ride. But then I have to see it again when I’m calm, when I know what’s going to happen plot-wise, so I can just watch how it’s put together and enjoy the craft in a deeper way. That’s when it can get great.
I have so many more to see from last year. Uh. I actually look forward to when the major awards are done and I can get back to my own film watching.
The biggest surprise of the movies this last month?
Dead Man. By Jim Jarmusch.
And it was released twenty years ago! How did I miss it until now? I absolutely fell for it, big time. I think this film is spectacular, maybe one of my all-time favorite modern films. I must see it again, and soon. Robby Muller did the cinematography. It’s not just a stunning black and white film, it’s funny, disturbing, painfully sad, and deeply beautiful. It has the perfect title. The Johnny Depp character is really dead from the beginning of the story, and it’s one long slow… and delightful… and truly scary… and ultimately dreamy death scene. It’s aurreal and harsh and demanding. Plus Iggy Pop in a dress! (I guess he’s often in a dress, but still!) Oh me, Oh my. I have so much admiration for Jim Jarmusch for making this particular film. If I ever met Johnny Depp, I would want to talk about Dead Man.
There’s a special awareness that comes over me when I watch films that are truly made by masters of the medium. That’s how I felt watching Bridge of Spies. I feel the same way about Roman Polanski’s films. And I don’t always love Polanski’s films or Spielberg’s! But I do feel as if I’m seeing extreme competence. There’s something about it that makes you relax into the film, like the conductor’s been at it a long time and knows what to do and you can just enjoy the view. I admired Bridge of Spies greatly. I think the Coen Bros. should write every film that Spielberg directs, while also writing their own films, naturally.
I think I’m not going to go there for the films I didn’t like too much. I would have liked The End the Tour more (the film is well made and nicely performed) if I cared about David Foster Wallace like I do about… well, say, George Eliot. I can’t get a toehold on Wallace’s prose. I don’t understand why he’s considered to be one of the greats. I’ve tried, believe me.
Now I’m laughing about the idea of a film about George Eliot like The End of the Tour, only I imagine myself in the David Lipsky role. HAHAHAHAHAHA that would be so friggin funny! “Mary Ann, really? I can stay in your guest bedroom? Can I watch you eat and walk around?” Will she say to me, “Believe me, you don’t want to be me.” ? ? And will I think, “No, I don’t want to be you, I want to be me, because now I get to write a book about you – No! About “us.” ? ?
Ahhh… jeez.
Well, until next month… I will try to answer any comments. Thanks for reading!
January 04, 2016 at 4:46 pm, snowdenlit said:
Welcome back. You were missed.
My work led me to spend a lot of time watching Nazi propaganda films. What interested me about Triumph was how much of it was devoted to promoting an image of Nazi unity just a few months after Hitler and Himmler decapitated the SA and executed (among others) Hitler’s closest ally in the regime, Ernst Rohm. Indeed, one of the reasons for making Triumph was to have a feature length documentary of a party rally day that didn’t include Rohm. Leni Riefenstahl’s previous party rally film, Sieg Des Glaubens, which strongly resembles Triumph (the opening of the Triumph is basically a shot for shot remake of Sieg, including the cat in the window) had Rohm all over it.
Only one print of Sieg Des Glaubens survives, because Riefenstahl left it in England during a visit there. The Prelinger archive has it, if you want to compare and contrast: https://archive.org/details/TheVictoryOfFaithsiegDesGlaubens
January 04, 2016 at 4:49 pm, Julia Sweeney said:
Oh wow! I’m so glad you wrote. I will look at it. I think Rohm is in Triumph just a teensy bit. Santori talks about him. Thanks!!
January 04, 2016 at 5:25 pm, snowdenlit said:
Though the memory of what happened to Rohm would have been fresh on the minds of Germans watching Triumph, he wasn’t in it. The Nuremberg Rally Triumph shows was held in September, 1934. By then, Rohm had been dead for two months. So unless Hitler staged a Nazi version of Weekend At Bernie’s with him…
The SA Leader you see in Triumph is Hitler’s handpicked successor for the job, Viktor Lutze. He occupies the same place Rohm did in Sieg during Hitler’s walk with Himmler from the Luitpold Arena podium to the World War I cenotaph. He also devotes his speech at the arena to pledging the SA’s loyalty to Hitler. (Himmler and Heydrich had ginned up evidence that Rohm and the SA leadership meant to foment a coup, which was the reason for the Night of the Long Knives.)
It’s funny just how much Triumph goes on about unity even though the regime was composed, in reality, of a mob of vicious office-seekers constantly stabbing each other in the back. For Hitler, who believed the strong should destroy the weak, this was a feature of his government rather than a bug. But he didn’t want the infighting to be too public, and he didn’t want his own position threatened.
January 04, 2016 at 9:40 pm, adabeie said:
This is a great list, and I love how you describe your relationship to the films you watch and the books you read. I’ll definitely be returning to this blog. And it’s way, way late, but thank you for your piece, Letting Go of God. It’s incredible and continues to be one that stays with me, makes me think and laugh no matter how many times I hear it.
January 05, 2016 at 7:57 am, Julia Sweeney said:
Thanks for the note and for liking “Letting Go of God” so much. That piece is opening in Poland this Spring, with an actress in my place - isn’t that wild?
January 04, 2016 at 11:23 pm, Hilary Grant said:
Oh, so many books and films! I enjoyed The Martian (and I just found out that the author of the book is the nephew of my across-the-street neighbor, right here in our little out-of-the-way beach town!), Spotlight, and OH, Brooklyn. You’re very into The Making of a Murderer, so please, watch Dear Zachary if you haven’t already! Very much looking forward to Carol. Saw the latest Star Wars movie last week because The Hubster and The Teenager Daughter wanted to. Great acting in a greatly mediocre script. If you’re on the fence about this one, don’t go! As far as books, I love essays and anthologies and memoirs… Ann Patchett wrote one of the former a few years back and I read it this last year. Lovely. Right now I’m in the middle of Elizabeth Taylor: The Accidental Feminist. Interesting POV, very academic, and I don’t agree with a good deal of it. But I went to high school with MG Lord, the author, so of course, I need to read it! And, yeah, it’s so difficult to post consistently, isn’t it? I post twice a month because it’s a writer’s blog, and it helps me stay fresh and focused. But it’s sometimes difficult to do! 🙂
January 05, 2016 at 7:56 am, Julia Sweeney said:
I haven’t seen Brooklyn. I loved the book so very much. “Elizabeth Taylor, Accidental Feminist” is such a great title! I want to read that too. I’m not sure I’ll get to Star Wars, that’s another series of movies that I just can’t get myself to delve into. It IS hard to write this measly blog entry, but I’m determined to keep it up this year. We’ll see. Thanks for writing!
January 05, 2016 at 2:30 am, Andy Bodnar said:
Same old Same old beurgois predictable film choices from you. With a few minor exceptions hardly anything out of the ordinary or left field. Just the same predictable super middle class film taste from you. I am not surprised you loved Clouds of Sils Maria. A few months before that came out Juliette Binoche gave a heartbreaking performance in Camille Claudel 1915 that puts Clouds of Sils Maria to shame. But I know you would never rave about that movie.
January 05, 2016 at 7:53 am, Julia Sweeney said:
I’m not sure why you read my blog, but I do appreciate the tip about “Camile Claudel 1915,” I’ll check it out.
January 05, 2016 at 11:42 am, Kate Dierks said:
Thanks for the book and movie list, I’m on it. Right now I am beginning Infinite Jest by David Foster Wallace, I saw a write up about it because of a film about him and wow it is a big book. I’ll let you know. Meanwhile it was sure nice to see a post from you. Stay sweet.
Kate
January 05, 2016 at 3:10 pm, snowdenlit said:
You should see “Camile Claudel 1915”. It’s a chilly picture, one I admire more than I like, but Binoche gives an excellent performance. Netflix had it on streaming a few months ago.
January 05, 2016 at 3:29 pm, Kate Dierks said:
It is a chilly picture, brrrr. Stil it isl worth the cold.
January 06, 2016 at 11:51 am, Hilary said:
Happy New Year Julia! I’m so happy to read your blog again. Your insights, reflections and humor mean a great deal to many people and I hope you continue to write. You’re a bright shiny voice on this wacky strange internet.
I highly recommend the Adrian Mole series by Sue Townsend. The books are silly and hilarious, but also become very moving and profound as the character ages from 13 to 40.
Thanks for your recommendations, and all the best to you!
January 07, 2016 at 9:41 pm, Greg said:
Hello, Julia!! Is the Evil Dead, or Army of Darkness your cup of tea. There is also a new Evil Dead series on Stars.
February 26, 2016 at 8:34 am, Julia Sweeney said:
Nah. I’m not into those kinds of stories. I try, or have tried in the past. But I’m just not… Yeah. It doesn’t take with me.
January 09, 2016 at 7:22 pm, Lisa W. said:
Julia, I am so glad you have returned to your blog! Having only known you from Saturday Night Live, you came to my attention when you appeared on The View several years ago (because I wondered what you were promoting at the time.) Which led me to Letting Go of God, your Jill & Julia show (saw you perform in Portland, OR), your book tour (saw you read at Powell’s in Portland, OR) and your blog! I have written down many book titles because you have mentioned them and I really appreciate you sharing your detailed thoughts about books, movies, your family and your life from a place of honesty.
January 22, 2016 at 3:57 pm, segdoh (@segdoh) said:
So glad you’re blogging again! You’ve inspired me: This will be my year of Middlemarch. I bought a beautiful hardbound copy ages ago, but it keeps getting displaced in my “to read” pile. I suspect that it’s a book that gains resonance as one ages.
January 30, 2016 at 9:26 pm, lottajoy said:
While watching LETTING GO OF GOD tonight, I heard you mention your voracious need to learn after “letting go”. I am at that stage now and can only believe my lack of motivation before was due to the stranglehold of being told “This is what you believe. No need to search further”. Now, I can’t stop searching, hope I never do, and I find the universe so fearfully fascinating. Thank you.
February 26, 2016 at 8:33 am, Julia Sweeney said:
You’re welcome. Yes. Isn’t it amazing how we learned not to ask questions? I think that’s the most dangerous aspect of religious doctrine, how it encourages people to shut down their natural curiosity.
February 26, 2016 at 11:30 am, Kate Dierks said:
Re: Being blindly lead w/o asking questions. Viva le question. A big amen!!
February 22, 2016 at 10:40 pm, Judy said:
Time to blog again!
February 26, 2016 at 8:32 am, Julia Sweeney said:
I know! I’m going to write something for March 1.